Published in the Geochemical News 109, October 2001
"Laser Ablation ICPMS in the Earth Sciences: Principles and Applications" Edited by Paul Sylvester, Mineralogical Association of Canada Short Course Series Vol. 29.
Although modern geochemistry is based on a large number of analytical techniques,
these comprise only a few main types and the development of a whole new class of
analytical techniques is relatively infrequent. The advent of inductively-coupled
plasma mass spectrometry (ICPMS) has revolutionized the measurement of elemental
abundances and isotope ratios in geological and environmental materials.
The coupling of ICPMS with in-situ sampling by laser ablation has yielded a new
class of technique, arguably capable of combining the spacial resolution of the
electron microprobe with the precision and sensitivity of the thermal ionization
mass spectrometer. Laser-ablation ICPMS (LA-ICPMS) has been in development since
the 1980s but it has only recently made the transition from an experimental technique
confined to a few labs to a mature analytical technique that can be employed by
non-specialists. The large number of quadrupole and magnetic sector ICPMS instruments
sold with laser ablation systems to Earth Science departments over the past few years
have vastly increased the number of potential users of this powerful method. However,
LA-ICPMS is hardly foolproof and a good understanding of the strengths and weaknesses
of the technique is needed to produce high-quality data.
To meet this need, the Mineralogical Association of Canada (MAC)
had published "Laser Ablation-ICPMS in the Earth Sciences: Principles and Applications"
edited by Paul J. Sylvester, the latest volume (#29) in the MAC Short Course Series.
This book covers the theory and application of LA-ICPMS to the measurement of trace
element abundances and isotope ratios in geological materials. Three introductory
chapters cover clearly and concisely the principles of quadrupole, single and
double-focussing mass spectrometry, plasma ion sources, data acquisition/calibration
and laser systems. The following four chapters explore the analytical nuances of
LA-ICPMS: the use of collision/reaction cells to mitigate isobaric interferences,
elemental fractionation during laser ablation, depth analysis and isotope ration
measurement. These seven chapters, several written by pioneers of the LA-ICPMS
technique, provide a well-rounded description of the method and constitute a valuable
reference for both experienced users and those new to the technique. The remaining
secen chapters cover a wide range of LA-ICPMS applications to topics and materials as
diverse as trace element analysis of fluid inclusions, and biological materials,
as well as U-Pb and Lu-Hf isotope geochemistry/geochronology of igneous and metamorphic
minerals. All of these chapters provide abundant details on instrumentation and
analytical strategy and rigorously address issues of standardization and data quality,
crucial for shaking the "semi-quantitative" label often attached to the LA-ICPMS
technique in the past. Several chapters also include useful comparisons with data
collected by competing techniques.
As an interested bystander to the world of laser ablation-ICPMS, I was very impressed by the depth and scope of the book. The discussions of how sampling variables (e.g., laser wavelength and power, geometry of ablation cell, type and flow-rate of carrier gas) affect ablation efficiency and inter-elemental fractionation, issues vitally important to the accuracy of LA-ICPMS data but often poorly understood, are particularly well explained. All of the articles in the book have abundant schematic drawings, photographs, time-series plots and tables that add greatly to the impact and clarity of the text. some cutting-edge applications, such as the measurement of mass-dependent stable isotope variations, are only briefly mentioned, but there is only so much that can be fit into a moderate-length volume encompassing the entire LA-ICPMS technique. This book is an extraordinary value for its modest price and it will prive to be a boon for all current and potential LA-ICPMS users. Moreover, it should be read by anyone wanting to understand the basic theory of the practical complexities of how chemical and isotopic data are collected via this powerful and increasingly widely used technique.
Review by Philip E. Janney

Review published in Economic Geology, 97,
2002.
Laser-Ablation-ICPMS in the Earth Sciences.
Paul Sylvester, ED. Short Course Series 29, Mineralogical Association of Canada. Price: $38 (US), $38 (CAN).
Advances in geochemistry are
often tied to technologic innovations that allow the analyst to make
increasingly precise measurements within the periodic table.
Analytic techniques have life cycles, some short, some long, but all
eventually subsumed by faster, cheaper, more precise upstarts. A
sort of technologic Darwinism prevails. Laser ablation (LA)-ICP-MS
(the reader is at liberty to liberally add or subtract hyphens to
the acronym) appears to be entering the early stages of maturity
judging from the publication of this new book. The book is the
outcome of a short course held at Memorial University, Newfoundland,
where substantive research and development of LA-Inductively Coupled
Plasma-Mass Spectrometry has taken place over the last decade. Not
surprisingly, the 14 chapters and three appendices covering the
basics of the technique and some recent applications in the Earth
Sciences, have a strong Newfoundland influence.
The book is well balanced,
with eight chapters covering theory and some practical analytical
considerations and six chapters focused on specific applications of
the laser ablation technique.
Seventeen authors contributed
to the book and the editor has done a good job of smoothing the
stylistic ups and downs that inevitably appear with such a large
number of authors. In the first chapter, Longerich and Diegor
provide a review of mass spectrometry with particular emphasis on
instrumentation used in conjunction with inductively coupled plasmas
and lasers. This provides a succinct introduction to the common
terms that newcomers to LA-ICP-MS are likely to encounter. This
chapter is followed by a discussion of chemometrics (a rather
nebulous term to describe the informational aspects of chemistry) by
Longerich, which deals with data acquisition and reduction. The most
technically advanced chapter is that of Simon Jackson, who discusses
the use of Nd:YAG lasers in LA-ICP-MS. In part, the latter provides
some preliminary information on the performance qualities of 266 nm
and 213 nm lasers, an important contribution on a critical subject
in its infancy. Gunther reviews protocols for in situ trace element
analysis of fluid inclusions using a 193 nm excimer laser; an
application with potential in economic geology. The use of collision
and reaction cells, now standard on the latest commercial
instruments to reduce or eliminate troublesome molecular
interferences for some elements, is discussed by Mason. Chapter 6
discusses the thorny problem of elemental fractionation (Gunther and
Hattendorf), a major unresolved concern in using this technique.
Depth analysis, an area of study that may ultimately have more
applications in material science than geology, is treated by Mason
and Mank. The final chapter in this opening set is perhaps the most
intriguing. Jackson, Pearson and Griffin provide an assessment of
the potential for the use of laser ablation in high precision
isotope analysis using an ICP as an ion source to a multi-collector
mass spectrometer (MC-ICP-MS). The prospects for ratio measurements
by direct laser sampling in previously unexplored isotope systems,
e.g., Fe, Cu are intriguing.
The chapters on applications
will prove more digestible to the readers who are more interested in
results rather then methodology. These chapters are limited in
scope, as might be expected in a relatively new technique, but
nonetheless, provide an assessment of the potential of the technique
in addressing practical problems in the Earth Sciences. The chapters
cover applications in U-Pb dating (Machado and Simonetti), bulk rock
trace element analysis (Sylvester), igneous petrology (Norman),
metamorphic petrology (Košler), economic geology (Sylvester), and
environmental geology (Veinott). These chapters clearly
illustrate that the major practical advances have been made in the
quantitative analysis of silicates and oxides, for the simple reason
that proven calibration standards (or at least one, NIST 612) are
available. Of course, the corollary is that the great potential for
this technique in economic and environmental geology awaits the
development of appropriate standards.
The title of this book is
somewhat misleading, in that it suggests a technique with a mature
background of methodology and a solid history of practical
application. In truth, the book demonstrates how much more is to be
learned about an analytical technique with tremendous potential in
the Earth Sciences, much of which is yet to be fulfilled. This book
will no doubt prove invaluable in introductory courses in laser
ablation ICP-MS, which are becoming increasing popular in academia
and professional societies. The Mineralogical Association of
Canada has kept the price well within the student budget, a rare
accomplishment these days. It should also be required reading to
laser ablation neophytes who are considering adding this
technique to their analytical arsenal. The price is sufficiently low
and the information content sufficiently high that I have several
copies scattered about my laser ablation laboratory for early
morning perusal whilst the instrument is warming up.
W. Ian Ridley
USGS
Mineral Resources Team
Denver, CO 80225

REVIEW published in
GEOSTANDARDS NEWSLETTER
Laser-Ablation-ICPMS in
the Earth Sciences (Principles and Applications)
Editor: Paul Sylvester
Mineralogical Association of Canada Short Course Series Volume 29, St John's, Newfoundland 2001. Series Editor: Robert Raeside.
I guess one shouldn't be
misled by artwork in science but one's first impressions on glancing
at the cover of this volume leads one to expect an exciting follow
up. There is a colourful monazite crystal from Makalu in the
Himalaya rastered by a 266-nm ND YAG laser. The purpose? A
232Th-208Pb age of 36.6 Ma. To whet one's appetite further there are
spectacular photographs of pits drilled in pyrite and molybdenite by
the 266nm laser and a 193-nm ArF excimer laser.
The volume, written by most of
the experts in the geological field at the present time, consists of
seventeen chapters including three in an appendix. Contributors
assembled in May 2001 to give a Short Course in Laser Ablation-ICPMS
(LA-ICPMS), sponsored by the Mineralogical Association of Canada, at
the Department of Earth Sciences, Memorial University of
Newfoundland, St John's, Canada. This institution has been at the
forefront of ICPMS development since the introduction of the
technique to the Earth Sciences.
The preface by chief organiser
Paul Sylvester introduces the subject briefly, reviews the history,
presents applications and speculates on future ones. LA-ICPMS has
been an important analytical tool since the early 1990's with earth
scientists being the major driving force. The reasons for this date
back to the 1960's and 1970's with the huge impact of the electron
microprobe and thermal ionisation-mass spectrometry (TIMS) on
mineralogy, petrology and geochronology. Geology evolved from a
field-based science to a dynamic combination of field observations
and laboratory measurements. However, these techniques had
limitations, the inability to measure a large number of elements
in-situ at very low levels, a few ppm or less. LA-ICPMS has
filled this void. As a result there have been significant advances
in igneous and metamorphic petrology studies. Major advances in ore
petrology and environmental studies are expected soon.
The recent development of
multi-collector magnetic sector ICPMS instrumentation has given
geologists the ability to make in situ measurements of isotopic
composition and age of tiny crystals and parts of minerals on the
scale of only a few microns. Isotopic ratios of elements such as Hf
and Cu, which are difficult and time consuming to determine by TIMS,
can be studied. This new data could change the way geologists view
tectonic, magmatic, metamorphic and sedimentary processes.
The first two chapters give a
useful introduction to ICPMS Mass Spectrometry and Chemometrics, the
data acquisition, calibration and data reduction as applied to
LA-ICPMS. This is followed by the Application of Nd:YAG lasers in
ICPMS. Early systems used the IR wavelength 1064 nm which is poorly
absorbed by many rock-forming minerals and therefore unsuitable to
laser ablation sampling. This chapter discusses the popular 266 nm
laser and recent work on a 213 nm system. There are articles on
fluid inclusion analysis using a 193 nm excimer laser, reduction of
interferences using collision and reaction cells, one on elemental
fractionation and another on depth analysis.
Mutli-collector ICPMS coupled
to a laser ablation system allows in situ isotope ratio
determination. This area is still in its infancy but holds enormous
potential. Recent developments and applications of Cu, Pb, Hf, Sr,
Nd and Os isotope analysis are discussed and another chapter is
devoted to U-Pb dating and Hf isotopic composition of zircon.
LA-ICPMS can also be used for
trace element analysis of whole rock samples either by fusing the
rock itself into a glass or better by mixing it with a flux,
typically lithium metaborate or lithium tetraborate, as in XRF
analysis. The latter method allows rapid and complete sample
digestion. An article reviews the history of this whole rock
analysis by LA-ICPMS.
For the geologist there are
two comprehensive contributions on the application of LA-ICPMS to
trace element geochemistry of basaltic magmas and mantle evolution
and a study of metamorphic minerals and processes.
Finally to complete a diverse
and enlightening volume there is a guide to platinum group analysis
of sulphides by LA-ICPMS, the use of LA-ICPMS in the Environmental
Sciences and in an Appendix what to look for in buying an ICPMS and
information on data reduction software.
Henry Longerich's considerable
contribution to ICPMS is highlighted by four articles in this
volume, the last one entitled, 'Why owning an ICPMS is like owning a
car'. Read on.
In conclusion, this volume is
a 'must' for anyone entering the field of LA-ICPMS. There is no
textbook that covers this new and fast developing area of
geoanalysis. Here we have a quality production with excellent
information for beginners and experts alike.
Phil
Robinson 14/1/02
School of Earth Sciences-CODES, University of Tasmania, Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
This book consists of 14
chapters and 3 appendices by a collection of authors who gave a
short course with the same title in 2001 at the Memorial University
Newfoundland. The analytical technique that hyphenates laser
ablation to a plasma-source mass spectrometer was given a great
boost by its early adoption in the mid-eighties by the research team
at MUN under the leadership of Henry Longerich. It is of course no
surprise that a large majority of the contributors has past or
present associations with MUN, but most are currently at other
laboratories worldwide using LA-ICPMS. This book has been produced
incredibly quickly and in my opinion that is more important than the
higher-than-average number of typos or the duplication of the first
8 pages in my copy. Speed of publication is very important in this
quickly evolving field where the vast majority of the references are
less then 5 years old and references from the 1980's are usually
qualified as 'classic' or 'seminal'. There is no index and only one
chapter with a glossary. Chapter 1 introduces the really basic
basics about mass spectrometry, down to units of pressure
measurement and types of vacuum pumps, but also some qualitative ion
optics and detector types. Chapter 2 gives the basics about making
analytical measurements and jargon of chemometrics, and lasers have
hardly been mentioned so far. The various types of lasers, and how
they are combined with the sample viewing optics, the ablation
chamber and ablation pit geometry, are discussed in the next group
of Chapters, each of which also deals with other aspects, without
too much overlap. Elemental (isotopic) fractionation is first
discussed in Chapter 3 but that topic which governs all attempts at
quantification, does re-appear in almost every subsequent chapter.
Chapter 4 deals with the Excimer laser and shows that the spatial
resolution that is achievable is sufficient to analyse fluid
inclusions in minerals that are as small as 10 micron in diameter.
Chapter 4 also discusses the merits of He (rather than Ar) as the
carrier gas in the ablation cell. Chapter 5 hardly deals with laser
ablation but instead gives the first discussion by an application
scientist of the workings and merits of collision and reaction cell
that are inserted by some manufacturers between the plasma expansion
chamber and the mass spectrometer. It is still limited to a
qualitative assessment of the various variables, but at least I have
the feeling that I am beginning to understand why these cells work.
Chapter 6 discusses elemental fractionation as a function of laser
wavelength and concludes that there are many reasons why elements
(and indeed isotopes) are fractionating but that laser wavelength
probably isn't the most important one. Chapter 7 discusses some of
the pitfalls of analysis during drilling into a sample. Chapter 8
introduces isotope ratio measurements with laser ablation hyphenated
to magnetic sector instruments and discusses mass spectrometer
geometry and performance for much analysed elements like Pb, Hf, Sr,
Nd, Os. Chapter 8 also touches on prospects for isotope ratio
measurements of transition elements and for U-series analysis, and
addresses various ways to correct for isotope fractionation. Chapter
9 is focussing on Laser Ablation for dating of zircon and some other
minerals. Zircon dating is an extremely important technique in the
Earth Sciences and has seen great investment in both time and
equipment, in the form of ion microprobes and while Laser Ablation
doesn't have the same resolution as SIMS, this is a large and
important application. However, yet again, isotope fractionation is
not easy to control and the need for good standards is paramount,
and that is true for both LA-ICPMS and SIMS. Chapter 10 is a bit odd
in that the most important advantage of LA-ICPMS, spatial
resolution, is abandoned by its use to analyse fused glass
dissolutions. This looks like using an available technique to do
something that can be done easier without it. Chapter 11 and 12 give
applications of LA-ICPMS to determine distribution coefficients
between minerals, and between minerals and melt which are of great
importance in geochemical modelling. Chapter 13 is again practical
and looks at the analysis of Platinum-group elements in sulphides,
and is largely a guide to the art of interference corrections. The
final Chapter 14 essentially lists a number of applications of
LA-ICPMS in environmental sciences, and points out the great
potential of the analysis of natural archives with spatial and, in
case of growth, time resolution. The book ends with two appendices
by Henry Longerich where he gives his thoughts on the purchasing
process of an ICPMS, but hardly touches Laser Ablation. Appendix III
gives a brief overview about the capability of one particular type
of software but offers no great new insights.
In all, this book is essential
reading for anyone who is about to explore the potential of
spatially resolved analysis by ICPMS. The book is as up-to-date as
can be in print, but the subject is nowhere near 'mature' and I
expect new versions (or maybe something similar but with
Environmental Sciences as its theme), to be superseding it within a
few years.
Dr Van Calsteren
Department of Earth Sciences
Open University
Milton Keynes,
UK

Review Published in The Mineralium Deposita in 2002
Paul Sylvester (ed): Laser-ablation-ICPMS in the earth sciences -principles and applications.
(Short Course Series Volume 29)
Mineralogical Association of Canada, St. John's, Newfoundland,
2001, 243 pp (ISBN 0-921294-29-8), Soft cover, S38US
The highly hyphenated technique of
laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) is one of the
relatively new weapons in the geochemists' arsenal of analytical weapons. It has been
described as an affordable trace-element microprobe, capable of direct quantitative
determinations of a wide range of elements. Despite the increasing popularity of the
technique, there has been no comprehensive text covering the subject, until the publication
of these papers which are the result of a short course given at Memorial University,
Newfoundland. Seventeen contributions cover the principles of the technique and practical
applications in the earth sciences. The editor has done a good job of balancing the
theoretical and practical aspects. The chapters are written by the current experts in the
field, and many were members of an illustrious analytical group at Memorial University.
This is not a "cookbook"; given the number of analytical variables
involved with this technique, and its flexibility, and I doubt if one will be written
anytime soon. It provides frank and cautionary discussions of the current capabilities
of the technique, and rightly implies that one requires a good deal of analytical experience
to use this technique productively.
The technique has found widespread application in igneous geochemistry, largely a function
of the availability of calibration standards. The lack of standards has slowed its
application in economic geology. One chapter discusses the use of the technique for the
analysis of PGEs in sulfide minerals, but the potential of the technique to many economic
geology studies is enormous, if unfulfilled. Neophytes and experienced analysts will find
value in this publication. Several chapters will prove useful in class courses, especially
as the book price is within the range of students, a rare attribute these days.
Ian Ridley